operational auditing indicators in the field of housing

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Motaher Audit Institute, Tehran, Iran

2 Islamic financial management

Abstract

Purpose:The main purpose of the present study is to design and calculate operational audit indicators in the field of housing.
Methodology:This research is a survey research of Delphi type.The statistical population of the research consists of experts and elites in the field of audit and operational audit, and they form 13 samples using the purposeful and judgmental sampling method. By using Raymond Kiwi method, dimensions, components and operational audit indicators were determined in the field of housing and then by asking the experts for their opinion, along with the fuzzy Delphi method, their consensus was obtained. After that, the TOPSIS fuzzy weighting method was used to determine the ranking of the indicators approved by the experts.
Findings:The results of this research showed that out of 38 operational audit indicators extracted from theoretical bases,33 indicators have obtained the general consensus of the Delphi group. In the dimension of economic efficiency, the non-financial component of the budget performance index and the cost of equipment to operating income, in the dimension of efficiency, the component of asset efficiency, the ratio of the use of materials per square meter and in the measure of effectiveness, the component of the effectiveness of the results of the index of compliance with long-term goals and strategies have been assigned a higher rank.
Increasing knowledge:The results of the present research show that companies can take steps to increase effectiveness, efficiency and economic efficiency by improving budget performance, using materials and matching long-term goals and strategies of the organization

Keywords


Smiley face

Afshari, A. & Mh. Salmasi. (2008). Investigating operational audit reporting issues of government agencies", Audit Knowledge. 28(1): 34-54. (in Persian).
Arjamandi, H. (2006). The framework of how to conduct an operational audit. Tehran: Operational Audit Institute. 66-88 (in Persian).
Afarmer Mohammad Hossein, Fazli Nejad; Javad. (2015). Legal requirements for the implementation of an operational audit in the Court of Accounts. Auditing Knowledge, 63(95): 269-288. (in Persian).
Baba Chani, J. Ghorbanzadeh,  A.  & P. Imanzadeh. (2018). mponents in Iran's public sector with an emphasis on environmental and social performance. Audit knowledge. 19. (in Persian)
Babajani, J. (2016). A model for the establishment of an operational audit system in public sector institutions of Iran, Knowledge Accounting and Management Audit Quarterly,6 (21). (in Persian)
Babajani; Jafar, Ghorbanzadeh; God's name, Imanzadeh; alliance. (2018). Explanation of operational audit components in Iran's public sector with an emphasis on environmental and social performance. Auditing Knowledge, 19 (2). (in Persian)
Creamy; Mansouri. (1400). A comprehensive review book on auditing (based on Iranian auditing standards), Gisum Publications, 9: 762. (in Persian).
driving; Alireza, Nasr; Mostafa. (2016). Challenges of the think tank in Iran. Scientific-Research Quarterly, Management and Development Process, 3 (12). . (in Persian).
Fatahi, S. Khoshnoud, E &  I. Gholi pour.  (2015). Investigating the Effect of Performance Auditing implementation on Improving Productivity of Governmental Sections of Iran (Case Study in the Supreme Audit Court). (in Persian).
Faridian, A. Emadzadeh, M. & A.  Rouhani (2013). The relationship between operational audit and reducing administrative corruption through increasing transparency, improving accountability and promoting trust and integrity", Danesh Audit Quarterly, 14th year, number 55: 29-5. (in Persian).
Fatahi, C. happy, I. & I. Qol Yapur. (2014). investigating the effect of implementation of operational audit on improving the productivity of Iran's public sectors. Audit knowledge15(61). (in Persian).
Ghasemi, M. Hijazi, R. & A.  Madahi. (2019). Designing a model for the operational audit of the Iran Oil Projects Company. (in Persian).
important Kaihan, Haiderpur; Farzaneh, Hosseini; Sayed Ali. (1389). Operational obstacles to the development of operational auditing in Iran from the point of view of managers of auditing institutions. Financial Accounting and Auditing Research, 8: 131-159. (in Persian).
Imani, M. (2014). Challenges facing mandatory operational audit in Iran's government agencies", Salamat Accounting Quarterly, 3(4): 1-19. (in Persian)
individual lawyer; Hamid Reza, Salehinejad; Maryam. (1388). Explanation and test of risk-based audit model in operational audit, Journal of Management Research, 83. (in Persian)
Karmi, Mansoori (1400). A comprehensive review book, According to the auditing standards of Iran, Gisom Publicztions, 90:762.
Like, J. William, F. Messier, Jr. & A  David. (2020). The Association between Internal Audit Operations-Related Services and Firm Operating Performance , ameican accounting association Journal 39 (1): 101–124. https://doi.org/10.2308/ajpt-52565
Muhammad Hasbi, S. & S. Almanita. (2019). Audit on Information System Function in Import Transactions Process PT. Bank Rakyat Indonesia (Persero) Advances in Economics, Business and Management Research, https://doi.org/10.2991
  Mahdavi, Gholam Hossein, Mohammadian; Mohammad. (2013). Challenges of performance audit implementation in executive bodies. Financial Accounting and Audit Research Quarterly; 9 (36). (in Persian).
Maham, K.  Haiderpour, F. &  A. Hosseini. (1389). Operational obstacles to the development of operational auditing in Iran from the point of view of managers of auditing institutions. Financial Accounting and Audit Research, 8; 131-159 (in Persian)
Nikbakht, Mr.  Rezaei, Z. &  V. Menti. (2017). Internal Audit Quality Model Design, Audit Knowledge17(69): 57-5. (in Persian).
Nalewaik, A. & M.  Anthony. (2015). Project Performance Audit: Enhanced Protocols for Triple Bottom Line Results 28th IPMA World Congress, IPMA 2014, 29 September -1 October 2014, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Operational audit committee of the audit organization. (2001). Acquaintance with operational audit, Auditor Quarterly, No. 10, 96-102(in Persian)
M ahdavi, G. & M. Mohamadyan. (2013). Challenges of implementing the audit function in executive bodies. Financial Accounting and Audit Research Quarterly. 9(36). (in Persian)
Rahimian, Nizamuddin. (1382). Operational auditing: a tool for accountability and management assistance. Auditor's Journal, 20(2): 3-19. (in Persian)
Respect Hamidreza (1385). The framework of how to conduct an operational audit. Operational auditing institute of Tehran. 66-88. (in Persian)
Rahdari, A. & M. Nasr. (2016). Challenges of the think tank in Iran. Quarterly scientific-research journal of management and development process, 3(12).  (in Persian).
Soghadah, Y.  Malekian,  E. & M. , Khanlari. (2015). Explanation of operational audit components in Iran's public sector with an emphasis on environmental and social performance. Audit knowledge.18. (in Persian)
Saifuddin Asl, Aa. Thaghafi, Aa. & Mm. Zulfiqarzadeh. (2015). Extracting the key indicators of research development with Ishikawa's fuzzy Delphi method for the healthcare sector. (in Persian)
Success, Yahya, Malekian; Esfandiar, Khanlari; Morteza. (2015). Explanation of operational audit components in Iran's public sector with an emphasis on environmental and social performance, 18. . (in Persian)
Success, Yahya, Malekian; Esfandiar, Khanlari; Morteza. (2016). Explanation of operational audit components in Iran's public sector with an emphasis on environmental and social performance, Mazandaran University, Faculty of Economic and Administrative Sciences. (in Persian)
Salgi Muhammad, Nobakht; Armin. (1401). Performance audit indicators. Scientific Quarterly Journal of Auditing, 29 (3): 475-503. . (in Persian)
Tabarsi, Ga. (1382). Explanation of cultural indicators (art sector indicators), Tehran, Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance, 22-23. (in Persian)
Vakili Fard, Hr. & M. Salehinejad. (2008). Explanation and test of risk-based audit model in operational audit, Journal of Management Research, 83. (in Persian)
Waring, Colleen. G. & Morgan, Stephen. L. (2007). Public Sector Performance Auditing in Developing Countries. In A.
Zarei, Mh. &  J. Fazel Yenjad. (2016). the legal requirements for the realization of an operational audit in the Court of Accounts. Audit knowledge.63(95): 269-288. (in Persian).
Volume 2, Issue 1 - Serial Number 5
Spring Quarterly
May 2025
Pages 121-144
  • Receive Date: 05 October 2024
  • Revise Date: 26 December 2024
  • Accept Date: 17 March 2025
  • Publish Date: 05 May 2025